Dr. David B. Adams – Psychological Blog

Psychology of Injury, Pain, Anxiety and Depression

Self Medicating

Diagnosis-by-Exclusion_ and why it would be such a concern?_

If a patient has complaints that are not readily verified, there are three choices:

a. Assume the patient is malingering

b. Assume other factors are forcing the patient to somatize (emphasize minor physical complaints/sensations)

c. Assume that more or repeated diagnostic studies should be ordered

The concept of diagnosis-by-exclusion is when we fail to consider the patient_s role in the complaints and look exclusively for physical causation. We do not look at the psychosocial variables until we have excluded every possible, even obscure, physical causes regardless of how improbable.

Case managers often do not consider the impact of other variables (marriage, drugs, crime, financial problems, depression, boredom, personality, etc etc) which are giving rise to the physical complaints until the patient makes consideration of such issues unavoidable. Since the patient most often lacks insight, the patient will continue to submit to repeatedly nonproductive diagnostic tests rather than deal with the true underlying reason they do not wish to return to work.

Once the pattern of diagnosis-by-exclusion has become the problem solving approach of an individual or a company, it is quite difficult to change, and a great deal of time and nonproductive expense is lost.

Comments for this post are closed.

Criminal Components in History

Let’s define the difference between problems and disorders. We all have problems: marital, financial, health, family, …
Read Blog Post

collateral damage

Collateral Damages

“Collateral Damages“ Personality disorders cannot be the target of injury-related care, and personality disorders do …
Read Blog Post

Patient’s Foundation

Decreasingly, when you are seen for any physical complaint, very little time is spent with you, and often you are seen by …
Read Blog Post