Dr. David B. Adams – Psychological Blog

Psychology of Illness, Pain, Anxiety and Depression

Permanent and Partial Disability

I had a patient who did not work until she was 38 years old. She then had ~20 jobs in the next four years; all were brief and there was no career pattern.

She also had a long drug history, is currently drinking heavily, was in two abusive marriages, had two hospitalizations (1+ years) for suicide attempt_and it gets worse from there.

She now has PTSD from a work-related injury.

Did the injury make her worse? Likely it did. But here is the most important part:
_ Treating her emotional problems under workers_ compensation would be doing her a disservice
_ She has bipolar disorder which coexists with, and contributes to, her PTSD. The bipolar disorder would be ignored if she were treated solely for injury related PTSD.
_ She has a clear history suggesting of addictive disorder driven by borderline personality disorder. Neither of these would be addressed under workers_ compensation.
_ Injury related psychological care would be inadequate to deal with her more pressing and potentially self-destructive pre-existing disorders.

In conclusion, treating an injury related psychological problem in patients with pre-existing severe emotional and addictive disorder is not only ineffective, it is unfair to the patient.

When there are data indicating past diagnosed (or even undiagnosed) and significant psychological problems, you must insure that such problems be addressed first and often separately from injury related problems. In doing so, you often find that the injury related _exacerbation_ then is no longer present.

Comments for this post are closed.

Injury as Punishment

Eighty percent of those who need care, never seek it. And many who seek it, do not benefit. Most patients who are referred …
Read Blog Post

Four Dead in Ohio

PTSD? Four Dead in Ohio

On Thursday, April 30, 1970, President Richard Nixon announced the movement of our troops into Cambodia (the Cambodian Incursion). …
Read Blog Post

misunderstanding

Misunderstanding

Misunderstanding one’s condition is a preventible complication. How does a patient approach understanding his/her condition? …
Read Blog Post