Dr. David B. Adams – Psychological Blog

Psychology of Illness, Pain, Anxiety and Depression

Pseudo Р“Posttraumatic Stress Disorders”

A worker lifted a machine part and strained his back at work two weeks ago. His attorney says that he needs care for posttraumatic stress disorder.

This is not a probable clinical diagnosis. There are psychological tests that measure the presence of PTSD, but the least accurate form is to ask the patient whether he/she feels she has the disorder.

In this case, the fatal flaws in the diagnosis arise from two sources:

a. He must have symptoms for at least a month to receive the diagnosis yet was injured only two weeks ago

b. The injury must have involved threatened death or threat to physical integrity and created intense fear, hopelessness or horror.

That would not seem to describe the injury in question.

Someone with true PTSD symptoms spanning at least a month would have recurrent dreams or intrusive thoughts and may respond strongly if exposed to the same setting in which the traumatic setting. Again, this would not appear to apply to your patient.

He would extend appreciable efforts to avoid thinking of the event, show diminished interest in his life, seem detached and/or fail to recall aspects of the injury.

He would also have sleep problems, irritability, and/or problems with concentration.

Comments for this post are closed.

Injury Case Deterioration

A probable diagnosis can be made based upon medical records without actually seeing the patient. Police Departments, the …
Read Blog Post

Diffuse Complaints

A patient complains of a range of physical complaints that do not logically follow from her injury. She injured her knee …
Read Blog Post

For Whom is Brief Care Effective or Ineffective

If someone truly does need psychotherapy following injury, what are the current standards of care…and why? For most …
Read Blog Post